Tuesday, October 2, 2012

'Rough Justice' review

Malvern Festival Theatre

ROUGH JUSTICE (Tom Kinninmont Production)

Tom Conti with Elizabeth Payne as prosecuting counsel
A gripping moral dilemma is presented in Terence Frisby’s brilliantly written, courtroom drama, Rough Justice. Tom Conti stars in the role of the accused, James Highwood, a public figure who has admitted to killing his infant son. He has decided to defend himself on a plea of manslaughter instead of murder and as the story evolves we, the jury, are encouraged to challenge the law and British legal system. The premise of this play is an excellent one but it is flawed in the fact that the audience, who are integrated into proceedings, are privy to information imparted outside of the courtroom, meaning that the ‘jury’ are not making a judgement on the facts presented to them but the actual facts of the case, which are ultimately conflicting. Therefore the post-show ‘chat’ is irrelevant and actually unnecessary. This however, doesn’t spoil the enjoyment of the production.

Conti is suitably arrogant as the TV journalist, accused of the heinous crime, and gives an epic performance, although there is no need for him to play for laughs, as he does on occasion, when the script so cleverly does that, relieving high tension with vital humour. Royce Mills is suitably pompous as the judge but his performance is unfortunately marred but his dependence on whatever is on top of his desk that prevents him from addressing anyone for any length of time, a technique that considerably diminished the climatic ending. Carol Starks gives an honest and endearing performance as the accused’s wife and David Michaels is brilliant as their, slightly awkward, legal representative, while Simon Murray, Mary Lincoln and Shaun Morton give perfect cameos as expert witnesses. The greatest accolade, however, must go to Elizabeth Payne for her stunning portrayal of the prosecuting counsel. This is an incredibly wordy play and she never errs once in her delivery, keeping the pressure on, as her role demands, throughout the entire play, giving a truly magnificent performance.

The subject matter of this production is fascinating and interestingly challenges the current legal system and the ethical and moral view on mercy killing and euthanasia. Rough Justice is an enthralling and engaging drama that is well worth seeing.

No comments:

Post a Comment